What is a fair price for a used Toyota Highlander in New York, NY?

The typical asking price is $24,800 across 717 listings seen in the last 7 days; the middle half ask between $13,500 and $33,600.

How many miles does a typical used Toyota Highlander in New York, NY have?

The median listing shows 76,000 miles.

A quarter of the listings ask under $13,500. 49 listings are asking 10% or more under fair price.

49 listings are asking 10% or more under fair price as of Oct 30, 2026.

717 listings in the last 7 days within 50 mi of New York. Typical price $24,800 (middle half $13,500–$33,600).

Updated Oct 30, 2026

Model years	Listings	Typical price	Typical mileage
2000–2002	7	$2,600	163k mi
2003–2005	25	$4,500	142k mi
2006–2008	52	$5,500	170k mi
2009–2011	36	$7,500	148k mi
2012–2014	57	$11,600	150k mi
2015–2017	70	$16,800	116k mi
2018–2020	134	$22,400	88k mi
2021–2023	249	$32,500	46k mi
2024–2026	87	$40,500	26k mi

2015 Toyota Highlander XLE137k mi · Carlstadt, NJAutotrader · Dealer · seen today
$11,995Fair price $15,710−24%
2008 Toyota Highlander Sport 4WD130k mi · Brooklyn, NYCarGurus · Dealer · seen today
$6,895Fair price $8,975−23%

What is a fair price for a used Toyota Highlander in New York, NY?: The typical asking price is $24,800 across 717 listings seen in the last 7 days; the middle half ask between $13,500 and $33,600.
How many miles does a typical used Toyota Highlander in New York, NY have?: The median listing shows 76,000 miles.
Where are the cheapest Toyota Highlander listings near New York?: A quarter of the listings ask under $13,500. 49 listings are asking 10% or more under fair price. Used cars under $15,000 in New York, NY
How many used Toyota Highlander listings in New York, NY are priced under market?: 49 listings are asking 10% or more under fair price as of Oct 30, 2026.