What is a fair price for a used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis, IN?

The typical asking price is $20,700 across 510 listings seen in the last 7 days; the middle half ask between $10,900 and $31,400.

How many miles does a typical used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis, IN have?

The median listing shows 106,000 miles.

A quarter of the listings ask under $10,900. 9 listings are asking 10% or more under fair price.

9 listings are asking 10% or more under fair price as of Oct 31, 2026.

510 listings in the last 7 days within 50 mi of Indianapolis. Typical price $20,700 (middle half $10,900–$31,400).

Updated Oct 31, 2026

Model years	Listings	Typical price	Typical mileage
2000–2002	13	$3,500	200k mi
2003–2005	19	$2,900	222k mi
2006–2008	41	$5,000	188k mi
2009–2011	39	$8,000	183k mi
2012–2014	47	$11,500	154k mi
2015–2017	80	$16,400	140k mi
2018–2020	96	$25,100	93k mi
2021–2023	143	$32,800	71k mi
2024–2026	32	$44,600	33k mi

2019 Toyota Highlander Limited117k mi · Fishers, INCars.com · Dealer · seen 1 day ago
$18,270Fair price $22,950−20%
2011 Toyota Highlander SE194k mi · Greensburg, INCars.com · Dealer · seen 2 days ago
$7,235Fair price $9,090−20%

What is a fair price for a used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis, IN?: The typical asking price is $20,700 across 510 listings seen in the last 7 days; the middle half ask between $10,900 and $31,400.
How many miles does a typical used Toyota Highlander in Indianapolis, IN have?: The median listing shows 106,000 miles.
Where are the cheapest Toyota Highlander listings near Indianapolis?: A quarter of the listings ask under $10,900. 9 listings are asking 10% or more under fair price. Used cars under $15,000 in Indianapolis, IN
How many used Toyota Highlander listings in Indianapolis, IN are priced under market?: 9 listings are asking 10% or more under fair price as of Oct 31, 2026.